Week 2: Brand Communities

BRAND COMMUNITIES

One of the suggestions for the Netnography project was Ryanair. In a first moment I thought that would be perfect because there has been so much complaints recently and not necessary the company is dealing properly. After the second lecture, though, I thought a problematic brand shouldn't be the only neither the main approach.

According to Muniz and O'Guinn (2001), on the paper "Brand Community", there are three core components or markers of a brand community:
  • consciousness of kind, is the perceived feeling of belonging;
  • shared rituals and traditions;
  • sense or moral responsibility, or shared obligation to the community and its members. 
Also, according to the last lectures, these are some of the characteristics of a brand community, such as Reddit:
  • organic
  • grows fast
  • people enjoy to be part of the group
  • not curated experience
  • users decide the content
  • moderators offers support and are not invasive
  • holistic view of culture
  • participative observation
  • members are passionate
  • members found other people that are passionate about the same things

From what I saw so far about Ryanair off and online, there isn't a brand community if we strictly follow the description above. I'm not even sure if Ryanair customers would identify themselves as having shared interests, once they make up a very heterogeneous group.

Bearing that in mind, I decided to have a look on different brands based mainly on the idea of brand community. That's what I came up with, again using the Ireland Customer Experience Report 2017 and comparing its results with the years 2016 and 2015.
  • Lush Cosmetics, made to the second position in 2017 and 2016, while it didn't appear in the top 100 in the 2015. About how Lush and The Body Shop interacts with their customers on social media. Searching on social medias, they have loads of different pages on Instagram, Twitter, Facebook and Reddit (only the ones I looked at), some of them from customers. On a quick search on Google, I could see there are some complaints as well, like ads displaying naked bodies, changing in the formulas, pushy staff or even the smell from their manufacturing plants.
  • Avoca: 43 in 2017; 21 in 2016 and 48 in 2015. The brand has been target of protests in Ireland because its owners, Aramark Group is one of the providers for the Direct Provision. An interesting article about Avoca and how they shape customer experience. Another interesting fact that called my attention is that Avoca is still been sold as an Irish family owned business, which is not the case anymore.
  • Parcel Motel: 6 in 2017, didn't appear in 2016 and 2015. Just a quick look on the internet and there has been a lot of complaints by the end of 2017 on. Maybe it worthwhile to have a look at.
  • PeterMark: 79 in 2017, 6 in 2016 and 53 in 2015. Even tough they say they value customer experience, in a quick google/social medias research I couldn't find any evidence on how the customer is heard and takes and active part in the brand.
Looking at the huge amount of information on different online channels and how they well interact with their customers, I decided to suggest Lush Cosmetics for the Netnography research. I think the brand has a kind of special appeal, as it's loved by many, is seen as socially responsible and is quite open to interact with the online community. These are part of their marketing strategy and some of the reasons why the company is doing so well.
Said that, I'm happy to go with whatever the group decide it's best.

Comments